So, I came across a chat post on Tumblr the other day titled “100 Reasons to Why You Shouldn’t Commit Suicide,” and I felt my pent-up constipation sink deeper into my lower intestines. Despite all I complain about, I don’t find many things truly offensive…but things like this that insult my intelligence offend me.
I believe the original poster’s heart was in the right place (assuming that the above link is the OP – I’ve seen it a few different places), but most of the suggestions on this list sound like shallow attempts at making an acquaintance feel better – things like “It gets better” and “Sherlock Season Three.” Not only do I feel like this list is dismissive of actual suicidal feelings, but this person also doesn’t understand that the desire to end one’s life is often caused by clinical depression (or the medications taken to control it), which can cause people to lose interest in things they once loved to the point where they feel life has no meaning. That means that these helpful hints would be useless in the long run, even if they can get you to crack a smile for a few useless minutes before you sink further down the spiral. (At least, that’s how it has always worked for me.)
That’s not to say that these things wouldn’t work for some people, but for me, repressing suicidal desires takes a lot more than some stranger on the internet telling me I’m beautiful. The only thing that has successfully stopped me from committing suicide lately is imagining that I’ve succeeded and having my ghost stick around long enough to watch the people I love (read: my young children) having a breakdown upon finding my body, and that is an ordeal I couldn’t bear to leave them with. But I understand everyone is different, and if butterflies and unicorns are enough to snap you out of it, then by all means, think of those.
Still, I’ve found other, similar lists on the internet, and all of them are equally trite and rage-inducing – and to the wrong person, it can make them go from suicidal to homicidal. Now, I’m no psychology major or therapist, but I’m an opinionated cynic with a past, and I’m going to deconstruct the “100 Reasons” list for all it’s worth:
100 Reasons To Why You Shouldn’t Commit Suicide
1. We would miss you.
To someone who has given up on life completely, this means nothing. Besides, remember when you graduated high school or said goodbye to your ex for good? Didn’t you hear (or say) something along these lines as well? Well, how long did that yearning last?
2. It’s not worth the regret. Either by yourself if you failed or just simply left scars, or the regret everyone else feels by not doing enough to help you.
I can agree with the first part of this – there is a great deal of shame involved with a failed suicide attempt (which may make the desire to end your life stronger). The second part, no – it is nobody else’s fault that you want to kill yourself. The pre-disposition for suicidal tendencies largely has to do with a chemical imbalance.
3. It does get better. Believe it or not it will eventually get better. Sometimes you have to go through the storm to get to the rainbow.
Without proper guidance and work to get where you want to be, life does not magically “get better.” There is help available for that if needed.
4. There’s so much you would miss out on doing.
There’s also so much suffering you would miss out on experiencing, which is probably more akin to what the suicidal person is feeling.
5. There is always a reason to live. It might not be clear right now, but it is always there.
Most atheists I know don’t even believe that we have a purpose in life (not to say none of them believe that, just many of the ones I know), so why would a suicidal person see the light at the end of the tunnel?
6. So many people care, and it would hurt them if you hurt yourself.
This actually isn’t bad advice, but once you’ve gone past the Despair Event Horizon, you can’t always see past the end of your nose. In fact, you may even start to resent the people who care about you for “keeping” you in this world.
7. You ARE worth it. Don’t let anyone, especially yourself, tell you otherwise.
If other people are telling you to commit suicide, they’re the ones that need to die, not you. (BTW, people like that are probably just trolls who sit down to a ham dinner on Sunday with a set of parents that only married each other because the snarky little troll was conceived out of wedlock and the abortion clinic was closed for lunch.)
8. You are amazing.
Everyone is amazing at something, but why would you casually fling this sentiment around at someone you don’t know very well, if at all? People can tell me I’m great all they want, but once they see that I have a dark side they usually side with the Sunday dinner trolls in #7.
9. A time will come, once you’ve battled the toughest times of your life and are in ease once again, where you will be so glad that you decided to keep on living. You will emerge stronger from this all, and won’t regret your choice to carry on with life. Because things always get better.
Again with the “things get better” line…isn’t that universally regarded as one of the worst things you can say to somebody struggling with depression? For what it’s worth, things don’t “get better” without taking steps to make things “better,” such as seeking proper help/guidance, eliminating negative influences, or even changing your attitude. And it’s not always an easy process.
10. What about all the things you’ve always wanted to do? What about the things you’ve planned, but never got around to doing? You can’t do them when you’re dead.
When the first thing on your bucket list is something as simple as, say, “Eat buffalo wings at Hooter’s” (that’s the first entry on my bucket list, anyway), it’s easy to be jaded by life. This statement is apparently targeted at teenagers who seem to know everything there is to know about the glass ceiling and the way the vagina works when it’s penetrated but apparently haven’t experienced jack shit when it comes to the real world.
11. I love you. Even if only one person loves you, that’s still a reason to stay alive.
Well now, if that isn’t condescending as hell…my former fiance loves me, but he’s also a high-functioning sociopath who would have become the next Elliot Rodger if he had stayed a virgin. In fact, I’ve often contemplated suicide just to get away from Zane’s obsession.
12. You won’t be able to listen to music if you die.
This might convince an atheist not to jump off a bridge, but I’m pretty sure most world religions view their version of the afterlife/next life as a celebration with fanfare (or something to that effect). Even in hell there will at least be death metal – isn’t that supposedly Satan’s music of choice?
13. Killing yourself is never worth it. You’ll hurt both yourself and all the people you care about.
Much in the same way as we are not responsible for “making” other people want to commit suicide, suicidal people are not responsible for the happiness of everyone else. Way to place that burden on ticking time bomb, OP.
14. There are so many people that would miss you, including me.
That may be, but remember, this entire list was typed out of some random Tumblrina’s ass, and was intended to be read by everyone comtemplating suicide – chances are, they don’t even know who you are. Hell, they could be that anon sending you hate messages right now.
15. You’re preventing a future generation, YOUR KIDS, from even being born.
I already have four biological children and have since gotten my tubes tied. Suicide doesn’t apply only to teenage scene girls…
16. How do you think your family would feel? Would it improve their lives if you died?
Honestly, most of my family either hates me or has given up on me. I don’t even talk to my family much anymore except online. In fact, I’m probably closer to my ex-husband than I am to my immediate family.
17. You’re gorgeous, amazing, and to someone you are perfect.
Everyone is somebody’s reason to masturbate. And that’s not necessarily a good thing.
18. Think about your favourite music artist, you’ll never hear their voice again…
Most of my favorite bands have stopped recording music. One band in question, Pink Floyd, put out their penultimate album over twenty years ago, and their next album is primarily instrumental. (I look forward to hearing it, though; I liked The Division Bell and David Gilmour’s On an Island.)
19. You’ll never have the feeling of walking into a warm building on a cold day
I hate the cold. In fact, the cold makes me feel more depressed.
20. Listening to incredibly loud music
That might drown out your suicidal thoughts temporarily, but it won’t make anyone around you glad that you’re alive…
21. Being alive is just really good.
Not always, and it’s arrogant to imply otherwise.
22. Not being alive is really bad.
I’d like someone with experience in that department to confirm that…but Nosferatu and I aren’t currently on speaking terms, so I’ll just have to sit in speculation for the time being.
23. Finding your soulmate.
Personally, I don’t believe in soulmates. And this strongly implies that it is imperative that every sad teenage white girl have a boyfriend to make things better – isn’t this what people hated about Twilight?
24. Red pandas
Aren’t they violent? Oh wait, this is obviously meant to distract somebody from committing suicide. It’s like the Arabian Nights or something.
25. Going to diners at three in the morning.
I’ve been to Denny’s at three in the morning…it’s like their witching hour or something. They also don’t replace the syrup in their soda fountains until daylight, from what I’ve experienced.
26. Really soft pillows.
Really? Like I’ve said before, a few mundane phenomena might get a suicidal person to crack a smile, but it won’t stop them from putting a gun to their head altogether. I’m not even sure if OP is trying, or if they’re just listing off personal turn-ons like Princess Kashmir in that one episode of The Simpsons.
27. Eating pizza in New York City.
I think Maddox already has something to say about this…
28. Proving people wrong with your success.
I’ve always believed that success is the best revenge, and that one day I would surpass my dissenters…but then I watched silently as these assholes escape their fate like Houdini on meth as I fell into two shitty marriages, perpetual unemployment, and a slew of other heartaches.
29. Watching the jerks that doubted you fail at life.
Isn’t this just the previous reason restated? OP is really grasping at straws here…
30. Seeing someone trip over a garbage can.
Isn’t schadenfreude something that leads other people to suicide?
31. Being able to help other people.
After they trip over the garbage can? Ah, I see what you did there…but seriously, how can somebody help other people when they can’t even help themselves?
32. Bonfires.
Only if I can burn my problems in them.
33. Sitting on rooftops.
I’m afraid of heights.
34. Seeing every single country in the world.
While that sounds exciting in theory, the reality is that the people this list was originally intended for would probably want to stay the hell away from places like the Middle East and North Korea – hell, most of them wouldn’t even go to Detroit in broad daylight.
35. Going on roadtrips.
I went on a roadtrip to Colorado once…it sucked. Not just because it was with my ex-husband, but because I hate sleeping in moving cars and peeing on the side of the freeway. But to each their own.
36. You might win the lottery someday.
Haha, that’s cute.
37. Listening to music on a record player.
While I don’t claim to be a hipster, I do think there’s something special about hearing music on a cassette player…but then again, that might just be nostalgia talking. By the way, you are aware that the music you listen to can affect your mood, right?
38. Going to the top of the Eiffel Tower.
Again, the heights thing.
39. Taking really cool pictures.
I’ve taken plenty of interesting photos in my time, but I’m no photographer.
40. Literally meeting thousands of new people.
A suicide bomber can have the best of both worlds.
41. Hearing crazy stories.
I browsed r/incest out of curiosity one day and I wanted to bleach my brain out. (I am so not linking to that Subreddit.)
42. Telling crazy stories.
You mean, like…rumors?
43. Eating ice cream on a hot day.
This might not be a good thing for the lactose intolerant (or those with a life-threatening milk allergy).
44. More Harry Potter books could come out, you never know.
I think J.K. Rowling’s incessant retconning to stay in the limelight has pretty much distanced me from the franchise. Besides, only the first five books were enjoyable to me.
45. Travelling to another planet someday.
Why, so the same people who ruined Earth can fuck up the next world?
46. Having an underwater house.
As much as I’d like to go to New Orleans and try authentic Cajun food someday, I just don’t see the appeal in an underwater house.
47. Randomly running into your hero on the street.
I recently had a daydream where I ran into Dexter Holland while walking down the street…okay, this reason is actually pretty good. Of course, you know what they say about meeting your heroes…
48. Having your own room at a fancy hotel.
I’ve been to plenty of hotels in my life…most I can’t remember, and the rest I don’t want to remember.
49. Trampolines.
Suicide in their own right.
50. Think about your favourite movie, you’ll never watch it again.
Granted, I’ll never get tired of seeing The Wedding Singer. Right now, my ex-husband is borrowing it, and if the fact that he constantly owes me money is anything to go on, I’ll probably never see my DVD again, either.
51. Think about the feeling of laughing out loud in a public place because your best friend has just sent you an inside joke,
Not something a socially awkward person would feel great about…
52. Your survival will make the world better, even if it’s for just one person or 20 or 100 or more.
With the exception of my underage children, I’m not responsible for other people’s happiness. Even your shrink can’t guarantee that their drugs and therapy will cure you.
53. People do care.
It’s not that suicidal people think nobody cares about them (though that can be the case), just that oftentimes they either a) don’t want to burden their loved ones or b) are aware that the people who care for them are unable to help.
54. Treehouses
Do people still have trees anymore? Do people still have property on which to grow trees anymore?
55. Hanging out with your soul mate in a treehouse
Tumblr is the hub for the sexual devolution – there are so many offshoots of asexuality springing up that AVEN has no energy left to try and be recognized seriously by the rest of the queer community. Granted, I know that “soul mate” isn’t synonymous with “lover,” but still…pitching this idea to a bunch of gender-confused teenagers probably isn’t the best way to advertise anti-suicide.
55. Snorting when you laugh and not caring who sees
I’m pretty sure I’ve already outgrown my need to impress people by now.
56. I don’t even know you and I love you.
That’s…creepy. Unless you mean in a religious sense, which can still be offensive to a lot of people.
57. I don’t even know you and I care about you.
You’d probably be sending me anon hate if you knew I’m not a feminist and I find demisexuals to be pretentious.
58. Because nobody is going to be like you ever, so embrace your uniqueness!
Either OP is trying to hard, or they’re just really relieved that there will never be an exact carbon copy of Adolf Hitler.
59. You won’t be here to experience the first cat world emperor.
Even if this didn’t trivialize the sensitive subject of self-murder, I would have complete faith that my cat Livvy would take over with the least resistance ever given during a coup d’etat.
60. WHAT ABOUT FOOD?! YOU’LL MISS CHOCOLATE AND ALL THE OTHER NOM THINGS!
Lots of people overeat when they’re depressed. And junk food like chocolate, when eaten in large quantities to the exclusion of all else, actually contributes to my chemical imbalance. I try to maintain a healthy diet of primarily produce to maintain both physical and mental health (but again, this doesn’t necessarily work for everyone).
61. Starbucks.
But what if you’re a Latter Day Saint? They only have, like, two Mormon-friendly drinks at Starbucks (yes, I checked). Besides, Starbucks doesn’t support our troops.
62. Hugs.
This probably wouldn’t work out so well for somebody who doesn’t like to be touched.
63. Stargazing.
Arguably, death could make you part of the cosmos.
64. You have a purpose, and it’s up to you to find out what it is.
I support GamerGate – do you still want to stop me from committing suicide?
65. You’ve changed somebody’s life.
Not necessarily for the better.
66. Now you could change the world.
Anita Sarkeesian became the Eva Perón of video games because she comes from (or married into) money and looks pretty. I’ve got more talent, common sense, and probably even education in my little finger than she does in her whole body, yet nobody’s heard of me. What could I possibly do?
67. You will meet the person that’s perfect for you.
There is no one person who is “right” for anyone else, at least, the way I see it. You find someone because you don’t want to be alone/need to breed/need money, tolerate them, and eventually die together. Sounds depressing to me.
68. No matter how much or how little, you have your life ahead of you.
That phrase doesn’t really mean anything. If the whole point is to change somebody’s mind about taking their own life, walk a mile in their shoes and consider the following: Is this person terminally ill and in constant pain? Have they done something so grievous that they can no longer live with themselves? Do they owe you money? If you really care about somebody’s life, try seeing things from their point-of-view and working that angle accordingly.
69. You have the chance to save somebody’s life.
As long as they don’t sue me for it afterward…hey, if it can happen to Mr. Incredible, it can happen to anyone.
70. If you end your life, you’re stopping yourself from achieving great things.
Money, power, and rumors also cockblock my creative success, but I’ve yet to see a meaningful solution to any of those problems.
71. Making snow angels.
It doesn’t snow where I live, a fact which I’m actually grateful for.
72. Making snowmen.
See #71.
73. Snowball fights.
Most guys I date aren’t into that sort of thing anyway.
74. Life is what you make of it.
So is death, if you think about it. But more to the point – if “life is what you make of it,” why do I need this condescending list telling me what my life has in store for me?
75. Everybody has a talent.
But when everyone is special, no one is.
76. Laughing until you cry.
The other day I went to a little toy shop in Seal Beach with Zane, and he cut the cheese so bad that it consumed the whole store. If I laugh about it any harder, though, I’ll die anyway.
77. Having the ability to be sad means you have the ability to be happy.
This works both ways, and to somebody with bipolar disorder (not me, even though Zane thinks otherwise), I’m pretty sure this isn’t a reason to want to live.
78. The world would not be the same if you didn’t exist.
The point of suicide is not to undo your existence, it’s to remove yourself from an existence you can no longer live in. If death meant that you were never born, no one would exist because we’d all have gotten away with murder.
79. Its possible to turn frowns, upside down
But a smile is usually the greatest form of deceit…
80. Be yourself, don’t take anyone’s shit, and never let them take you alive.
Doesn’t this contradict the point of this list?
81. Heroes are ordinary people who make themselves extraordinary. Be your own hero.
This makes me think of the “an hero” meme (which I’m not overly excited about, but there you go). And villains fit the same definition…see #66 on this list.
82. Being happy doesn’t mean that everything is perfect. It means that you’ve decided to look beyond the imperfections.
That’s not happiness, that’s contentment, if not outright Stockholm syndrome.
83. One day your smile will be real.
I thought that the whole point of this list was to give suicidal people a legitimate reason to be happy. Now what?
84. Having a really hot, relaxing bath after a stressful day.
I’m pretty sure that when you’re suicidal, every day is a stressful day to begin with.
85. Lying on grass and laughing at the clouds.
I don’t smoke pot.
86. Getting completely smashed with your best friends.
Gee, there’s no way that could possibly end badly, amirite? What’s that you just coughed into your hand, “eight grapes”? Is that some sort of Persephone reference?
87. Eating crazy food.
Well, I’m hungry right now, so I guess I can give ’em this one.
88. Staying up all night watching your favourite films with a loved one.
That’s assuming you’ve already scratched off #55 on this list. Or maybe you can kill two birds with one stone (as it were) by watching movies in the treehouse.
89. Sleeping in all day.
Isn’t that actually a symptom of depression? I know I’m personally happier when I’m more productive. Which is good, because I have, you know, responsibilities, and I can’t exactly sit on my ass all day…
90. Creating something you’re proud of.
…Then living long enough to see it be usurped, stolen, perverted, or destroyed.
91. You can look back on yourself 70 years later and being proud you didn’t commit
I’m 26 years old…I’m pretty sure I’ve got about 50 years left, at best. In fact, don’t most human beings only live to be in their 70s in the first place?
92. Being able to meet your Internet friends.
I’ve met two guys in person that I’d previously only met online. Both times ended in heartache and eventual regret.
93. Tea / Coffee / Hot Chocolate
Violation of Doctrine & Covenants Section 89. (Well, not the hot chocolate, but still…)
94. Sherlock season three.
I’ve seen it. It’s enjoyable, but I would have prefered a sixth season of Fringe instead.
95. Cuddling under the stars.
What’s with all the cuddling and stuff listed? OP is assuming that everyone attempting suicide is some teenage demi-vierge who can be cheered up with a beaded friendship bracelet and a cup of warm cocoa. Maybe some advice as to how there are ways to recover from being laid off at work or wrongly accused of sexual harassment…but that would mean you have to know your audience.
96. Being stupid in public because you just can.
I’m pretty sure you can get arrested for that. And again, a lot of suicidal people suffer from social anxiety so…
97. If you are reading this then you are alive! Is there any more reason to smile?
Actually, reading this patronizing bullshit makes me want to die.
98. being able to hug that one person you havent seen in years
Maybe said person is already dead…you do the math.
99. People care enough about you and your future to come up with 100 reasons for you not to do this.
I was offended enough to come up with 100 snarky responses to this listicle, does that count? Besides, many of these “reasons,” besides being trite and dismissive, were also just restatements of the first twenty questions or so.
100. But, the final and most important one is, just, being able to experience life. Because even if your life doesn’t seem so great right now, literally anything could happen
While this isn’t false, I reiterate: not everyone considering suicide is a first-world teenager whose problems can be hand-waved with a list of quirky non-sequiturs.
It took me months to finish this rant (it usually only takes me a day or two to write these things) because I couldn’t wrap my head around it. I’d like to say it was a good concept with a bad execution, though coming from Tumblr – a site where people regularly reblog crap like “remember to eat and not cut yourself because I love you!” but unfollow you at the drop of a hat if you post something questioning feminism – I took it as mental masturbation more than anything else.
But in all fairness, this list could potentially help someone, even for a moment. If you can manage to find anything worth living for in this crapsack world, so long as it doesn’t hurt you or anyone else, then by all means, live for it.